Town pages for local SEO: when they help and when they hurt
A page for each town you cover can win you searches, or it can drag the whole site down. The difference is whether each page says something true about the place.
Somebody offers to “do your local SEO” and a week later your site has sixty new pages. Plumber in Skipton, plumber in Settle, plumber in Grassington, plumber in Hellifield, each one the same four paragraphs with a different town dropped into the gaps. It looks like a lot of work for the money. For a month or two, a couple of them might even appear in Google.
Then the enquiries flatten off, and the pages that used to bring them in start slipping as well. Pages like these can do real harm, and the reason sits in how Google judges a site as a whole.
Why a page per town can work
When somebody searches “boiler repair Settle”, Google looks for the page that answers that search best. A single “areas we cover” page with Settle listed alongside nine other places is a weak answer. A page about your work in Settle is a strong one. Our post on why a site does not show up for nearby searches covers this alongside the other things that decide local rankings.
So the idea behind town pages is sound. A business based in Skipton that does a lot of work in Settle and Ilkley has a fair case for a page about each, because customers in those places search for the service with the town name attached, and a page written for them answers that search better than a list does.
The trouble starts when the page exists to catch the search and has nothing to say once somebody lands on it.
What Google calls a doorway page
Google’s spam policies have a name for pages built to rank for a set of near-identical searches, each funnelling the visitor towards the same place: doorway pages. Its own examples include pages targeted at particular cities or regions that funnel visitors to one place, and substantially similar pages that read more like search results than a site somebody would browse. Sixty copies of the same text with the town swapped in fit that description exactly.
Since March 2024 Google has also had a policy against what it calls scaled content abuse, which covers pages produced in bulk mainly to rank, whether a person writes them, a template fills them in or a machine generates them. The town page factory is one of the oldest versions of it.
Google does not need to catch these by hand. Its systems compare pages, and a set of sixty that share ninety per cent of their words looks like what it is.
How thin pages drag down the rest of the site
The obvious cost is that the copied pages do not rank, or rank for a short while and then fall away. That would be a wasted fee and nothing worse.
The bigger cost is to everything else. Google now judges helpfulness partly at the level of the whole site. When a large share of your pages exist for search engines rather than for people, that counts against the site, including the pages that were doing well before. Your home page, your service pages and your best blog post can all slip because sixty empty pages sit beside them.
The numbers matter here. A small business site might have fifteen or twenty pages a customer would want to read. Add sixty copied town pages and three quarters of the site is now filler. Google sees the site through that ratio.
In the worst case a manual action follows: somebody at Google reviews the site, confirms the spam, and the affected pages or the whole site drop out of the results until you remove the pages and ask for a review. You would find that message in Google Search Console, if anybody has set it up for you.
What makes a town page worth having
A good town page passes a simple test. Somebody living in that town should learn something from it that they could not learn from your home page. A few things that pass:
Work you have done there. A photo of a job on a street they would recognise, with a line on what the problem was and how you fixed it. Ask the customer before you name the street.
How the place differs for your trade. Older stone terraces in one town, newer estates in another, a conservation area with its own rules, hard water, steep lanes a van struggles with. A roofer, a joiner and a solicitor will each have different things to say, and that difference is the content.
The practical detail. How quickly you can get there, which postcodes you cover from that side, whether you charge for travel, and where you park on a busy market day.
Something from a local customer. A review from somebody in that town, quoted with their permission, does more than any amount of copy you write about yourself.
None of this needs to be long. Three hundred words of true, local detail beats a thousand words of filler. If you sit down to write the page for a town and cannot find anything specific to say, that tells you the page should not exist.
How many to have
Fewer than most people expect. Start with the two or three places where you already do a fair amount of work and want more, and where customers search with the town name. Your enquiry records will tell you which ones, and so will the search terms in Google Search Console if it is set up.
Write those well, link to them from your areas page and from the relevant service pages, and leave the others on a single, well-written page covering the rest of the area you serve. Add another town page when you have enough real work there to say something about it.
A business with five honest town pages is in a far stronger position than one with sixty copies, and five is something you can write yourself over a couple of quiet afternoons.
If you already have dozens of copied pages
Do not delete everything in one go without a plan. Check in Search Console which town pages bring any visits or enquiries. The few that do are worth rewriting properly. The rest can be removed and redirected to your main areas page, so anybody who bookmarked one still lands somewhere useful, and so any links pointing at them still count.
Expect a few weeks before Google re-crawls the site and the change shows. The recovery is gradual, as the damage was.
The short version
A town page earns its place when it tells somebody in that town something true about working there. Copies with the name swapped are what Google’s spam policies describe, and enough of them can pull down pages that had nothing to do with them. Write a few properly, starting with the places that already send you work, and fold the rest into one good areas page.
If you are not sure which of your location pages are helping, or whether the ones somebody added for you are doing damage, our SEO work starts by finding out. A free website review will give you a first look at the same question.



